Good gnocchi are soft, light and almost cloud-like. Bad gnocchi are dense, gluey and rubbery. The difference comes down to moisture, flour and a gentle hand. This guide covers why potato choice matters, how to make potato gnocchi step by step, how to cook and serve them, and how ricotta and other types differ.

Is gnocchi pasta?

Strictly, gnocchi are dumplings. Pasta is a dough of wheat flour and water or eggs, kneaded to develop gluten. Gnocchi are a mash of potato (or ricotta, semolina or squash) bound with just enough flour to hold together. In Italy they are served as a first course, the same slot as pasta, which is why they are usually grouped with it. The distinction matters in the kitchen: gnocchi dough should not be kneaded like pasta, because gluten makes it tough. For related ideas see our pasta types guide.

Why gnocchi turn mushy or gummy

Almost always it is moisture. The wetter the potato, the more flour you need to hold it together, and the more flour you add, the denser and chewier the gnocchi become. Overworking the dough also develops gluten, which makes them rubbery.

A white bowl of cooked potato gnocchi garnished with fresh sage leaves

Choose the right potato

Bake, don’t boil

Boiling adds water to the potato. Baking whole potatoes dries the flesh. Many cooks bake them on a bed of coarse salt, which helps absorb moisture. Cook at about 200 °C (400 °F) for 45 to 60 minutes, until soft all the way through.

Basic potato gnocchi recipe

These quantities are a starting point. Potatoes and flour vary, so adjust as you go.

  1. Bake the potatoes whole until very tender.
  2. Rice while hot. Cut them in half, scoop out the flesh, and pass it through a potato ricer or food mill onto a clean work surface while it is still steaming. Hot starch absorbs flour readily, while cold potato needs more working, which builds gluten. A ricer makes light, even fluff. A masher compresses it.
  3. Add flour gently. Sprinkle about three-quarters of the flour over the potato, add the egg yolk and salt, and fold with a bench scraper until it just comes together. It should look a bit shaggy. Add more flour only if it is too sticky to handle. Do not knead.
  4. Roll and cut. Divide into portions, roll into ropes about 2 cm thick, and cut into 2 cm pieces.
  5. Shape (optional). Roll each piece along a gnocchi board or the back of a fork to make ridges. They hold sauce better.
  6. Test one. Drop a piece into simmering water. If it falls apart, mix a little more flour into the dough.

The egg question: purists, particularly in northern Italy, make gnocchi with only potato and flour, which gives the lightest result but is harder to handle. An egg yolk helps bind the dough with little added weight.

How to cook gnocchi

  1. Bring a large pot of salted water to a gentle simmer. A rolling boil can tear them apart. See pasta water for the salt and water basics.
  2. Add the gnocchi in batches. They sink, then float to the surface after 2 to 4 minutes. Give them another 30 seconds, then lift them out with a slotted spoon.
  3. Do not overcook, or they become waterlogged.
  4. Toss them gently in the sauce. See mantecatura for the finishing method.

Pan-searing and baking

Pan-seared

Boiling is the classic method, but pan-searing is popular, especially for store-bought gnocchi. Cook them in a skillet with butter or olive oil over medium-high heat for a few minutes per side, until golden and crisp on the outside while soft inside. Brown butter and sage works well.

Sheet-pan

Toss shelf-stable or chilled gnocchi with cherry tomatoes, sausage or vegetables and oil, and roast at 200 °C (400 °F) for about 20 minutes. The tomatoes burst into a natural sauce.

Ridges: aesthetics or function?

They help. Ridges increase the surface area and give sauce something to hold on to. A smooth gnocco is slippery, and a ridged one holds ragù or brown butter. A fork works as well as a wooden board.

Ricotta gnocchi dressed with butter and sage

Types of gnocchi

TypeBaseTextureKey tipSauces
Gnocchi di patate (potato)Russet potato and flourSoft and pillowyBake, rice hot, minimal flourBrown butter and sage, ragù, gorgonzola
Gnocchi di ricotta (gnudi)Drained ricotta, Parmesan, eggLight and milky, more delicateDrain the ricotta wellFresh tomato, butter, light pesto
Gnocchi alla romanaSemolina cooked in milk, butter, egg yolksDense and creamy, baked as discsCook like polenta, cool, cut, then bakeButter and pecorino, baked
Parisienne gnocchiChoux pastryLight and airyPipe into simmering waterGruyère or Mornay sauce

Ricotta gnocchi: an easier starting point, since there are no potatoes to bake and peel. Drain the ricotta thoroughly before mixing. Cauliflower gnocchi: cauliflower is mostly water, so steam it and wring it out hard in a cloth before using, or the dough will be too wet.

Troubleshooting

Gnocchi dissolve in the water

Not enough binder, or the water was boiling too hard. Fold a little more flour into the remaining dough, and use a gentle simmer.

Gnocchi are tough and rubbery

The dough was overworked. You cannot fix the dough, but you can bake them in a generous tomato sauce with mozzarella, which softens the effect.

Dough is too sticky

Dust with a little flour and fold it in. Do not knead.

Sauces and pairing

For other sauce matches, see our pasta pairing guide and sauces guide. If you enjoy twisted shapes, try gemelli. For thick, sauce-grabbing shapes see radiatori and ruote, and for a soft, comforting alternative in soups, pastina.

Storing and freezing

Common questions

Can I make gnocchi without a ricer?

Yes. A box grater’s fine side also works. Avoid a traditional masher, which compresses the potato.

How do I know when gnocchi are cooked?

They float to the surface after 2 to 4 minutes. Lift them out soon afterwards.

Are gnocchi gluten-free?

Usually not, since they contain wheat flour. Gluten-free versions use alternative flours.

Are gnocchi vegetarian?

Yes, with potato or ricotta, though some use egg. Check the sauce too.

Can I use leftover mashed potato?

It is usually too wet and seasoned with butter or milk, so the result is heavier. Baked and riced potato works better.

More reading

For inspiration, see BBC Good Food’s gnocchi recipes. For the basics of cooking, read pasta cooking, and for slips to avoid, common pasta mistakes. You can also compare with strozzapreti and alphabet pasta, two other fun, hand-shaped or novelty types.

Related guides: check typical times in the cooking time chart, or browse the pasta shapes A to Z.